Two Dental Chews, Two Approaches to Oral Care
If you're looking for a daily dental chew for your medium-sized dog, the Pedigree Dentastix Bulk Pack and the WHIMZEES Alligator are two popular options that approach teeth cleaning differently. The Pedigree Dentastix is a classic X-shaped stick designed for daily tartar reduction, while the WHIMZEES Alligator is a vegetarian, grain-free chew with a knobby shape aimed at cleaning between teeth and freshening breath. This comparison focuses on what the labels actually tell you about ingredients, dental action, and size compatibility so you can choose the right one for your dog.
Ingredients and Dietary Considerations
The ingredient profiles of these two chews are quite different, which matters if your dog has sensitivities or you prefer a specific diet approach.
- Pedigree Dentastix – Low fat, no added sugar, no artificial colours or flavours: Pedigree Dentastix are described as tasty but low in fat, with no added sugar and free from artificial colours and flavours. They contain active ingredients that help reduce plaque and tartar. The label confirms they are a complementary pet food for dogs over 4 months.
- WHIMZEES Alligator – Vegetarian, grain-free, six primary ingredients: WHIMZEES Alligator chews are made with only six primary ingredients. They are produced sustainably with no artificial ingredients, colors, flavors, preservatives, GMOs, gluten, or meat. They are also low fat and rich in vitamins and antioxidants, plus fiber to promote regularity. Suitable for dogs from 9 months old.
Dental Action: How Each Chew Works
Both products claim to reduce plaque and tartar, but they use different mechanisms.
- Pedigree Dentastix – X-shape and gently abrasive texture: The unique X shape and gently abrasive texture are designed to be chewed long enough to be effective, with active ingredients that help reduce the build-up of plaque and tartar. The brand claims they are scientifically proven to help reduce tartar build-up by up to 80% when fed daily.
- WHIMZEES Alligator – Knobby shape and grooves for between teeth: The knobby shape is intended to ensure proper blood flow through the gums and prevent bad breath and tartar buildup. Hollow shapes and spaces allow teeth to easily grip and chew, with grooves that get in between smaller spaces. They are proven to help clean teeth and freshen breath by reducing plaque and tartar as the product is chewed.
Size and Weight Guidelines
Getting the right size chew is important for safety and effectiveness. Here is what the labels specify for medium dogs.
- Pedigree Dentastix – For dogs 10–25 kg: Each stick is designed for medium dogs weighing between 10 and 25 kg. The bulk pack contains 105 sticks, making it a convenient daily option.
- WHIMZEES Alligator – For dogs 12–18 kg: Each alligator chew is suitable for medium breed dogs from 9 months old weighing between 12 and 18 kg. The pack contains 12 chews.
Product Facts at a Glance
- Pedigree Dentastix Daily Dental Chew - Medium Dog - 105 Stick Bulk Pack: Pedigree Dentastix Daily Dental Chew are uniquely X shaped dental sticks that are scientifically proven to help reduce tartar build-up by up to 80%, when fed daily. This claim supports the product's primary purpose of daily tartar control for medium dogs.

Pedigree Dentastix Daily Dental Chew - Medium Dog - 105 Stick Bulk Pack - WHIMZEES Alligator Medium Dental Chew Dog Treat - 12 pack: Whimzees Daily Dental Treats are proven to help clean teeth and freshen breath by reducing the build up of plaque and tartar as the product is chewed and moved around the mouth. This confirms the chew's dual benefit of cleaning and breath freshening, which may appeal to owners concerned about bad breath.

WHIMZEES Alligator Medium Dental Chew Dog Treat - 12 pack
Which One Should You Choose?
If your priority is a daily, low-fat, budget-friendly stick that fits a wider weight range (10–25 kg) and you don't mind that it contains some processed ingredients, the Pedigree Dentastix Bulk Pack is a solid choice. The 105-stick pack offers good value for daily use.
If your dog has food sensitivities, or you prefer a grain-free, vegetarian, all-natural chew with no artificial anything, the WHIMZEES Alligator is the better fit. Its unique shape is designed to clean between teeth, and it may help with breath freshening. However, its weight range is narrower (12–18 kg), so check your dog's size carefully.
Neither product is a substitute for regular veterinary dental care, and both should be given as part of a balanced diet. Always supervise your dog when offering any chew.



