Whimzees Toothbrush vs Soft Chews: Dental Treats Compared
By Petplanet | Published: 2026-10-29
Category: Comparisons
Compare Whimzees Toothbrush and Whimzees SOFT Value Bag to find the best dental chew for your dog. We break down the key differences in texture, cleaning action, and suitability for different dogs.
Quick answer
Choose the Whimzees Toothbrush for a more aggressive plaque-removing chew with grooves and ridges, or the Whimzees SOFT Value Bag for a gentler, easier-to-chew option that still supports daily dental health.
Texture and chewing effort
The main difference between these two Whimzees treats is their hardness. The Whimzees Toothbrush is a standard-texture dental chew designed to be gnawed thoroughly, with grooves and ridges that scrape plaque and tartar as the dog chews. The Whimzees SOFT Value Bag is 35% softer than the standard Toothbrush or Adult Stix, making it noticeably easier to break down.
This means the SOFT chews are better suited for dogs with sensitive mouths, senior dogs, or those who are not enthusiastic about hard chews. The Toothbrush, on the other hand, provides a more intense mechanical cleaning action that benefits dogs with moderate tartar buildup and a normal chewing style.
Portion size and daily routine
The Whimzees Toothbrush Medium comes in a 75-pack, offering a larger quantity for medium-sized dogs that need a daily dental chew. The Whimzees SOFT Value Bag contains 28 smaller chews, which are ideal for small breeds or as a lighter daily treat. Both are designed to be given once per day as part of a consistent dental care routine.
If you have a medium or large dog that chews vigorously, the 75-pack of Toothbrush treats provides better value per chew. For a small dog or a dog that only needs a gentle cleaning, the SOFT Value Bag is a more appropriate portion size.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Cleaning intensity: The Toothbrush uses grooves and ridges for aggressive plaque and tartar removal. The SOFT chews rely on a gentler chewing action that still helps reduce buildup but with less scraping force.
- Chew difficulty: The Toothbrush is a standard hard chew that requires persistent gnawing. The SOFT chews are 35% softer, making them far easier to break down for dogs with weaker jaws or sensitive teeth. If your dog abandons hard chews, the SOFT version is more likely to be finished.
- Pack size and value: The Toothbrush Medium 75-pack offers a larger quantity for daily use over a longer period. The SOFT Value Bag 28-pack is smaller and better suited for smaller dogs or as a trial size. For a medium to large dog, the 75-pack is more economical per chew.
Product facts
- WHIMZEES Toothbrush Medium Dental Chew Dog Treat - 75 Pack: Grooves and ridges on a Whimzees Toothbrush help remove plaque and tartar like never before. Engineered for the way dogs grip and chew. This design provides a more thorough mechanical cleaning action, making it a strong choice for dogs with visible tartar who enjoy a good chew.
WHIMZEES Toothbrush Medium Dental Chew Dog Treat - 75 Pack - Whimzees SOFT Value Bag Small Dog Chews - 28 Pack: WHIMZEES by Wellness SOFT is 35% softer than WHIMZEES by Wellness Adult Stix or Toothbrush which make it easier to chew on. Perfect for the soft chewers or senior dogs. The softer texture makes it accessible for dogs with dental sensitivity or reduced chewing strength, while still supporting daily dental health.
Whimzees SOFT Value Bag Small Dog Chews - 28 Pack
Which one fits your dog?
Best for
- Dogs with moderate tartar buildup that enjoy a firm, textured chew
- Medium to large dogs that can handle a standard-hardness dental treat
- Owners who want a larger bulk pack for daily use
Not ideal for
- Senior dogs or those with dental pain or sensitive gums
- Small breeds that may struggle with the harder Toothbrush texture
- Dogs that prefer a softer, easier-to-chew treat
